Showing posts with label faithfulness to standards of truth. Show all posts
Showing posts with label faithfulness to standards of truth. Show all posts

08/02/2007

commonplace argument

While chatting to the Library's IT consultant I was struck by how commonplace argument has become a forum of falsity; not from the consultant's practice, but her account of an exchange over drinks with a person masquerading as a philosopher.

The object of any discussion, to determine what is being talked about, to clarify terms, and to formulate the stronger argument seems to have been abandoned; together with the common courtesy of assuming the other discussant(s) are able to discern non-declared aspects of the cut and thrust of argument.

Now any speaker in this new practice has an agenda, a narrative, to be driven home roughshod over logic, reason, clarity, honesty, hinterland knowledge, or acceptance of the aims or means of discussion (all this apart from both the openly aggressive and the implied rudeness in presentation).

Religion is like this - belief not enquiry, certainty not hypothesis, and the whole persona committed to victory not enlightenment. When this manner of conducting oneself in the world started up again I am unsure; but it will lead to such horrors, has done so already since it was last repelled over 60 years ago.